Committee Secretary
Community Affairs Committee
Department of the Senate
PO Box 6100
Parliament House
CANBERRA. ACT 2600
Felicity Brazil, MAPP
Founder, Strong into Superb
Friday 22 March 2024
Submission to the Standing Committee on Community Affairs inquiry into issues
related to menopause and perimenopause.
To the Senate Inquiry Committee,
Thank you so much for instigating this inquiry and I appreciate the opportunity to make a formal submission to it. My submission is dedicated to everyone who has shared their stories about their menopause journey with me, which has included all genders and ages. Their openness and vulnerability inspire me daily to continue to support their wellbeing during this time.
I am a wellbeing scientist and practitioner focused on mentoring professional women during their menopause journey through the business I founded – Strong into Superb. My passion on supporting wellbeing during menopause grew when I was perimenopausal and studying for my Master of Applied Positive Psychology, also known as wellbeing science. I then became post-menopausal due to the removal of my ovaries in 2021 and there was limited support for the hormonal impact this had on my life. Thankfully, I did not have cervical cancer. However, this meant I was not ‘eligible’ for support through the Ovarian Cancer society and nor did my surgeon offer any post-surgery support for menopause. This increased my passion to support wellbeing for all during menopause, so that others could have the evidenced-based support that I did not. In February 2024 I started the first pop-up Menopause Cafés (Cafés) in Canberra, both in person and online, which occur monthly. The Menopause Café movement started in Perth, Scotland, in 2017 and has spread worldwide, with volunteers now hosting pop-up events in the UK, Bahrain, Mexico, USA, Austria, India, and Australia. These cafés are aimed at breaking down the stigma around menopause and increasing awareness of the impact of the menopause on those experiencing it, their family, friends, and their colleagues. For further information on these Cafés and feedback on their effectiveness in supporting people during menopause, please refer to Appendix A.
My submission relates to the Inquiry’s Terms of Reference (a) to (i), with the following key points:
I make the following recommendations to the Inquiry (in no order of priority):
A. Capture women’s positive menopause continuum experiences and start sharing their
B. Educate children in high school about menopause.
C. Ensure that there is a standard approach in measuring and evaluating vasomotor and genitourinary symptoms, including the efficacy and effectiveness of clinical and non-clinical interventions.
D. Have information targeted at women’s partners about menopause, and this includes same-sex partners.
E. Have not-for-profit community-based support groups where all ages and genders can come and discuss all things menopause by adopting nationally the pop-up Menopause Cafés (for further information on these Cafés and feedback on their effectiveness in supporting people during menopause, please refer to Appendix A.)
F. Normalise menopause and destigmatise it through embracing women’s aging through promoting that women are valued as they age, and that menopause is a natural part of life.
G. Promote evidence-based wellbeing pathways to support wellbeing during the menopause continuum at work, so that women grow through it rather than just getting surviving and/or being resilient.
H. Provide evidenced-based information to all families about menopause to destigmatise it. Have this information in multiple languages and culturally appropriate.
I. Provide information on menopause to service businesses who are in close contact with women so they can promote fact and evidence-based menopause information. For example, hairdressers, beauticians, and shop assistants in women focused stores.
J. Provide women from 35 onwards information about the menopause continuum to help her support her wellbeing before and during it based on evidence-based information, ensuring it discusses the reasons why each experience is unique due to her biological and psychological functioning, demographics, and lifestyle choices, and influenced through her relationships, work and the society and culture in which she lives.
K. Research how a woman’s menopause experience impacts the wellbeing of her family unit and her communities, and vice versa.
L. Research the effect on family wellbeing during menopause and identify evidence-based wellbeing pathways to support it both proactively and reactively.
M. Women from 35 years of age are eligible for subsidised bone density screening to identify any potential impact on bone loss during menopause continuum and action to address any concerns found.
Terms
In this submission I use the following terms:
What is Wellbeing?
Wellbeing, from the lens of positive psychology, is at the heart of helping individuals and communities thrive and surprisingly there is no agreed definition for wellbeing. 14 I have chosen to use a definition that focuses on the individual wellbeing: “wellbeing can be understood as how people feel and how they function both on a personal and social level, and how they evaluate their lives as a whole”. 15 Research suggests that the wellbeing of an individual impacts, and is impacted by, all the people, workplaces, groups, societies, cultures within which it takes part1, there is complexity in understanding the conditions that help wellbeing thrive 2,3, and there is shared responsibility of individuals, organisations, and communities to improve wellbeing of all. 4 Wellbeing science “is the scientific investigation of wellbeing, its antecedents and consequences”. 16 As this field grows, so has the identification of evidence-based ways to guide, support and educate people to create the best possible wellbeing journeys for themselves, their families, workplaces and groups. Wellbeing through the lens of positive psychology excludes wellness concepts that require clinical support such as medical healthcare, health products such as nutritional supplements and medication, food, and personal care products. 17
Menopause Continuum Impact on a Woman’s Wellbeing
There six factors that may impact a woman’s lived experience through her menopause continuum (refer Figure 1). At the individual level, there are four factors: biological and psychological functioning, demographics, and lifestyle choices. 10,18-21 Fifth, psychosocial refers to how her social structures and practices influence her social, spiritual, emotional and mental health. 5 Finally, sociocultural refer to how her socioeconomic status and her cultural and societal influences that may impact her health, behaviours, thoughts and feelings. 22 These factors may influence a woman’s biological and psychological symptoms during her menopause continuum.
Figure 1
Model of Six Factors That May Impact Women’s Menopause Continuum Experience
Note. These symptoms may be due to more than hormonal changes
As woman’s biological changes may result in vasomotor symptoms, hot flushes and night sweats, and physical symptoms such as joint pain, fatigue, and brain fog. 10,21 She may also be affected by genitourinary symptoms, such as vulvovaginal dryness and pain during sex. 23 Psychologically, she is more likely to suffer from depression and vasomotor and genitourinary symptoms if she has a history of mood disorders, views menopause negatively, had adverse experiences during childhood, lacks effective coping mechanisms, and/or has a low level of self-compassion. 18-20
Her risk of experiencing biological and/or psychological symptoms is also influenced by the other four factors: lifestyle, demographics, psychosocial, and sociocultural. For example, this risk may be due to a lifestyle that includes limited exercise, cigarette smoking, significant alcohol intake and/or being overweight. 10,19 Demographically it may be due to having lower literacy and education levels 24,25 and/or their geographical and racial background. 9 Psychosocially it may be due to a negative attitude toward menopause and/or aging, being under stress, and/or having limited support. 18 Socioculturally, it may be due to unemployment or experiencing workplace issues. 24
Recent surveys of women’s quality of life during their menopause continuum indicate that they do not always feel good nor function well as they are bothered by biological, psychological, and social symptoms including: dissatisfaction with their personal life, feeling depressed, having difficulties in sleeping, and accomplishing less than before the start of their menopause continuum. 26,27 The length of time a woman may experience biological and/or psychological symptoms could also impact a woman’s wellbeing during her menopause continuum. For women who experience menopause continuum biological and psychological symptoms, it is suggested they are experienced on average for 7.5 years during menopause transition and 4.5 years after a woman’s final menstrual period. 28,29 However, these findings may not be reliable, as there has been no standard approach in
measuring and evaluating symptoms, including the efficacy and effectiveness of clinical and non-clinical interventions. 11,30,31 Finally, it is posited that symptoms may last longer given there is limited cross-sectional data available and postmenopause symptoms are not often followed up.9
Conversely, positive experiences for some women are that it is a relief to be in her menopause continuum and embracing the menopause continuum as a normal life transition with no need to be concerned about pregnancy and menstruation postmenopausal. 6,11 Women’s attitude towards her menopause continuum may even be more positive after they have finished it, counter to their perceptions beforehand. 32 However, a woman’s positive menopause continuum experiences are rarely sought. 6 The menopause continuum is also not experienced the same worldwide, given the influence of psychosocial and sociocultural factors on a woman’s wellbeing. 7,8 Geographical and racial backgrounds of women appear to determine their likelihood of having symptoms and how they are experienced: the reasons why, in addition to the six factors that may influence every woman’s experience, are not yet fully understood. 9 Further, it is also not experienced the same within a country, as even if women’s demographics are similar in other ways, the experience of women who lived through a particular cultural era may not be comparable to a woman from a different generation. 10 Women who migrate to a new country appear to report similar menopause continuum symptoms and attitudes that are dominant in their new country as opposed to their previous country. 11 Wellbeing pathways with research suggesting that may alleviate menopausal symptoms at the individual layers include:
In summary, a woman’s menopause continuum is influenced at the individual level by her biological and psychological functioning, demographics, and lifestyle choices. Her menopause continuum is also influenced through her relationships, work and the society and culture in which she lives. The influences of these factors means that every woman’s menopause continuum is unique, acknowledging the multiplicity of individual and socio-factors impacting a woman’s menopause continuum that may affect her quality of life.5,6
Recommendations
Menopausal Continuum Wellbeing Impact on Others Wellbeing
Women’s wellbeing is also impacted by, and impacts, the wellbeing of her family, friends, community, and society within which she lives. 1,4 This interaction is visualised in Figure 2. The first factor, biological, influences, and is influenced by, the physicality layer. The second factor, psychological, influences and, is influenced by, the layers of: consciousness, emotions, cognition, and behaviour levels. Lifestyle and demographic factors influences, and is influenced by, all individual layers. The fifth factor, psychosocial, influences, and is influenced by, the immediate social setting relationships and their interaction. The sixth factor of sociocultural, influences, and is influenced by, the immediate social setting relationship to social systems inclusive.
Figure 2
Multidirectional Influence on Women’s and Others Wellbeing During Menopause Continuum
Note. Adapted from “The complex creation of happiness: Multidimensional conditionality in the drivers of happy people and societies,” by T. Lomas and T. J. VanderWeele, 2021, The Journal of Positive Psychology, 18(1), p.19 (https://doi.org/10.1080/17439760.2021.1991453).
Recommendations
Why Family Wellbeing Needs to be Supported During the Menopause Continuum
It is suggested that a woman’s menopause continuum marital satisfaction and attitude towards her menopause continuum is affected positively the more their partner is educated about the menopause continuum. 44 Research has also shown that high levels of family support decreases a woman’s psychological distress during her menopause continuum. 36 These points in turn may influence the family’s wellbeing during menopause.
There is a dearth of literature on the impact of the menopause continuum on family wellbeing. Yet, in 2021 within Australia there were 5.5 million couples with children and 1 million lone parents with children, where over 800,000 women were the lone parent. 45 When a woman is in her early forties, she is entering the so called ‘sandwich years’, where she may enter the menopause continuum, have dependent children, be a carer of elderly parents, be in a relationship, and be working. 46 In 2021, the Australian median age for a woman to be married is 27.2 years, at separation is 39.1 years, and at divorce is 42.8 years. 47 Single parent families headed by a woman, of which there were over 800,000 in Australia in 2021 47, and are often financially vulnerable. 48
In 2019, the mean age for an Australian woman to have her first child was 29.7. 49 Australia, a higher income country, has an average age for her natural final menstrual period of 50 years 50 and, with menopause continuum negative symptoms being experienced on average for 7.5 years prior to her final menstrual period 28,29 , suggests that the mean age of her first child at commencement of menopause continuum may be 12.8 years. This is the age when children are in early adolescence, a period of biological changes and psychological development and includes sensitivity to stress within the family context. 51
For those women with children, a parent’s physical and mental health has been shown to impact the whole of the family system and its functioning, which in turn impacts their children’s wellbeing. 12 When a parent is physically and mentally healthy, it is suggested that they have better parenting skills due to more effective emotion regulation, decision making, life satisfaction and stress management, and contributes to supporting child wellbeing. 12 A parent’s coping mechanisms and warmth to their children predicts their children’s ability to cope and level of wellbeing in adulthood. 52 Children’s mental health is negatively impacted by family conflict and positively associated with the positivity of both parents. 53 Parenting beliefs and level of involvement are also different by nationality, culture, and gender. 54 Single people, including those who are separated, divorced, or widowed, have higher life satisfaction if they have positive relationships with self and others. 55 These positive relationships also provide reciprocal protective mental health support in helping to mitigate experiences of depression and stress. 12,56. Newland 12 identified three interrelated factors are foundational to improving family wellbeing: (a) family members’ individual wellbeing; (b) family self-sufficiency where a family can meet their own basic needs; and (c) family resiliency in which family relationships and personal growth are strengthened through positive management of conflict and stress. This suggests that if a woman’s wellbeing is negatively impacted during her menopause continuum, it may negatively impact the wellbeing of her family. So, I suggest that both the number of family members providing support along with the positive quality of this support shapes a family member’s wellbeing, the families wellbeing, and wellbeing of society 13,56.
Recommendations:
If you would like to discuss any part of my submission you may contact via website (https://www.strongintosuperb.com/contact-us/)
Your sincerely,
Felicity Brazil
Full submission with Appendix A and references
Appendix A – Menopause Cafés Overview and Feedback